The title makes me look like an expert on the subject. Of course I'm not. However, it doesn't mean I can't at least try to sound intelligent.
I've been thinking of writing about this for some time. Then, sure enough, I saw another article on it titled:
Why Don't People Like Mercy?. I would bet many people have been reflecting on this theme. Even the
Eye of the Tiber had an article:
"Well, that was a complete bust," Francis tells crowd moments before cancelling remainder of the year of mercy. It seems that things have not gone as planned. This great year of mercy has come off as a bust. Not for all, thankfully, but in general it has been shrouded with indifference. That is indeed too bad. I'm sure Pope Francis had great and noble expectations for this year.
Yet God, yes in His mercy, can bring some good out of it. For starters, we can do some soul searching, and thus learn how to improve. So why hasn't the year of mercy panned out? And how can we get it back?
1) Logo
Marketing fascinates me. Product. Brand. Name. Z-Form. Light usage. What is portrayed. Marketing is important. Now mercy is not about marketing. Yet, the "brand" associated with mercy can certainly impede the message. The official logo for the year of mercy is a disaster. There is nothing appealing about it from the colour-scheme to the design, and especially to the three-eyed Jesus/sinner. What is the message? It is lost somewhere between the late 1960's Catholicism and the straight up weirdness.
2) Disconnect with St. Faustina's Divine Mercy
Following on the official logo, many Catholics were very surprised that St. Faustina's Divine Mercy image was not the official logo. Why not? It is tried, tested, and true. It inspires devotion. What is more, and yes I speak of private revelation, it was commissioned by Our Lord Himself. Catholics immediately connect this image with mercy. Can you imagine if a country was going to host the Olympics and they already had a perfect stadium, one that has successfully held huge events in the past, all ready for use. But the country instead decides to build a new stadium, based on modern art design. The new stadium fails. The old one sits vacant. No one understands why. That sort of is the feel with St. Faustina's Divine Mercy image.
3) No Need (as believed by some)
We all need mercy. Yet there are some who still believe they do not. In my own parish there used to be a priest, years and years ago, who would tell everyone in confession that they hadn't actually sinned. "And I hit my brother..."
"That's not a sin!" "Oh, well I lied to my teacher..."
"That's not a sin!" And on and on it went like that. Years later very few people go to confession in this parish. Even with the current priest ALWAYS waiting in the confessional. The people have been numbed into believing they are generally good people, and thus do not need confession. A year of mercy, then, is for doing nice things for the poor. Nothing more. This severely cheapens what mercy really is. God came to call sinners.
4) Mercy = License
Of course, some have taken the message of mercy too far, to the point that God forgives all things we do, whether we truly repent or not. As I stated in my previous blog post, Fr. Rolheiser was insinuating this belief on facebook, and people were eating the message up. One person accused me, after I quoted the catechism, of putting my own interpretation on the catechism in such a way as to limit God's love. All I said was:
"CCC1033 on Hell: 'We cannot be united with God unless we freely choose to love him. But we cannot love God if we sin gravely against him, against our neighbor or against ourselves.' It is certainly possible for heresy, sexual immorality, or even willfully abandoning the Church precepts, to constitute a grave sin."
Nope. To suggest dying in the state of mortal sin can put us in hell is to use the catechism against God's love. Or so I was told.
Once mercy/love is used as a license for whatever goes, it actually does not become mercy anymore. It becomes a license for relativism.
5) Overplayed Message
For a while at Mass it seemed as if every statement made by the priest or commentator had to begin with: "In this year of mercy..." For instance: "In this year of mercy, let us begin in the name of the Father, and of the Son..." or, "In this year of mercy, let us offer our intentions to the Lord..." or, "In this year of mercy, there will be coffee and cake after Mass." It's been over done. Such that a zoning out has occurred. It's natural to zone out an overplayed message. Just like an overplayed song on the radio. People tune out.
6) A Touch of the Bizarre
By bizarre I mean not so much in concept as in appearance, especially to those less familiar to the Catholic Church. First there was confusion over the sin of abortion being forgiven only in the year of mercy, as if it wasn't forgiven before. This is nonsense. Then there is the deal with the priests of the Society of St. Pius X. Confessing to them during this year of mercy will actually forgive your sins (faculties). But confessing to them the day after this year of mercy will not. I hold out hope that Pope Francis is working at resolving this issue (!). Also we've learned about these Missionaries of Mercy, mercy priests?, who have special orders from the pope to deal with different situations. Finally, there's the whole deal concerning the doors of mercy. Pass through this door and obtain mercy. There is actually a pious tradition behind this, though I think it could have been better explained. For instance, I have not once heard mentioned the conditions required in order to obtain a plenary indulgence. People who walk through the holy doors and expect to go straight to heaven when they die may be saddened to hear there are other conditions attached. All in all, to the non-Catholic, or even casual Catholic, there is a hint of oddness to this year.
7) Synod
It cannot be understated how the recent Synod on the Family, and accompanying exhortation
Amoris Laetitia, has dampened the joie de vivre of many Catholics (myself included). The obsession of many on Communion for those living in adultery has been promoted by some (Kasparites) as mercy. This should have been squelched a long time ago. Yet it continues to linger. Love without Truth is not Love at all. Promoting mortal sin is the opposite of mercy. The effects of the Synod have scarred the year of mercy.
What can be done?
WYD
The year of mercy is certainly salvageable, but action must be done quickly. There is a tremendous opportunity for a revival of this holy year. I speak of World Youth Day (WYD). Although I don't care for WYD, I do see a golden opportunity based on WYD's location: Poland. Poland is, of course, where the message of Divine Mercy was received by St. Faustina. Poland holds dear to this message. It is at WYD that Pope Francis should go all out in reconnecting the year of mercy to Divine Mercy. The pathetic year of mercy logo should be mysteriously dropped. In its place should appear the true image of Divine Mercy. World Youth Day must draw from the Diaries of St. Faustina. The youth of the world should be introduced to this spiritual treasure. Further, given that this is Poland, a special appeal to Pope John Paul II's love for Divine Mercy, as well as the story of St. Maximilian Kolbe, should be evident. From WYD a turning point in the year of mercy can occur.
Year of Mercy
Following WYD, the words "year of" should also mysteriously start vanishing. If God's mercy is so important, which it is, then we should prepare to hear about it beyond this year of mercy. Not in the annoying and over done "In this year of mercy..." sense. But instead an "Our Lord is
dying to forgive you! Come to confession!" sense. Mercy will continue beyond this year. Hopefully more people will be going to confession, beyond this year. Think long term. This connects with my final point...
Clarification
There are many other things that could be said. Ultimately what is needed is for Pope Francis to step up and state the obvious: people living in an objective state of adultery must refrain from Holy Communion. He can hug them, cry tears with them, even kiss their babies, but ultimately the year of mercy needs an injection of clarity. Clarity on what is, and isn't, mercy. Clarity on what is sin, and how the Church can help. Without this clarification the year of mercy will continue to lack appeal for many faithful Catholics. It will continue to lack depth. It will continue to fail. In short, we
need to know we are sinners! Only then will we understand our need for mercy. This year of mercy needs more sin! For, as St. Peter says:
"He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree, that we might die to sin and live to righteousness. By his wounds you have been healed." 1 Peter 2:24