There is good reform.
And there is bad reform.
Though in fairness to the bad reform, we wouldn't get pick up lines like this without the likes of Luther and Calvin...
Today many ill-informed, evil, or just plain stupid Catholics are celebrating the 500th anniversary of the Reformation. I am commemorating another day. It was ten years ago on this day I got my first true glimpse of ecumenism.
Yes, I was studying at Redeemer University College. A Calvinist-esque place where I intended on quickly finishing up my degree and getting the heck out of there. I could tell something was up leading up to October 31st. There were posters speaking of the upcoming Reformation Day. So the day hit. I more or less expected it to be the usual Halloween style day. Some people dress up. Some don't. Maybe a prof hands out candy. Whatever. But that day wasn't at all like that.
Let's just say where I grew up in late fall it is hunting season. Well at Redeemer, in my experience of Reformation Day, it was hunting season on Catholics. The Reformation was constantly brought up in class and in the hallways. Catholicism was frequently ridiculed, mocked, and sneered at. It was all very eye-opening. But what else could I expect? I was on their soil, so to speak. I sucked it up that day. I took my punches. The sin of being a Catholic. A proud Catholic.
But just as with the counter-Reformation, I doubled down the next day and counter-punched Protestant ideas all the more fiercely at class. A couple of profs appreciated this. Others definitely not. And that, I believe, is the ecumenical movement. In other words, what ecumenical movement? The fuzzy show of unity is a mask. There are differences that will never be overcome. There is bitterness that will continue. No surprises. We just deal with it. And we certainly don't celebrate it.
Yes, 500 years of Luther and his kin. A parting shot Luther: If you were saved, it was only through the merits and grace of the Catholic Church.
Now that wasn't a very ecumenical thing to say was it?




